
A less technical definition comes from Harvard Business School, which defines medical tourism as the act of "traveling far and wide for health care that is often better and certainly cheaper than at home" — a practice that appeals to patients who needs simple procedures such as a acupuncture or dental work to more complicated interventions like heart bypass and organ transplant. The practice is also known as health tourism, medtrotting, or cross-border health tourism. The primary reason for medical tourism is to receive "the same or better care at lower cost."
Medical tourism is booming and has now become on last count a $40 billion dollar industry. An estimated 10,000 Americans engage in medical tourism annually, not including cosmetic surgery and dental procedures. Other estimates range from 50,000 to 500,000, including all procedures. Most American medical tourists are uninsured or are seeking an unapproved procedure, or one that is not covered by their insurance." In 2005, about 150,000 people worldwide were medical tourists. Singapore, Thailand, Malaysia and India are the leading countries in medical tourism industry and Mexico, Costa Rica, Turkey, Israel, Australia and New Zealand are entering the market, to name a few.
Though it has become very popular only in recent years, medical tourism is not a new phenomenon. Indeed, hundreds, even thousands of years ago, people have been to known to visit areas known for their healing powers, e.g. thermal baths, mineral waters, etc. In England, the World Heritage City of Bath got its name from the numerous heated mineral springs and roman baths that became quite popular with the rich and famous of Europe of the 17th and 18th century.
The word "Spa" is taken from a little Belgian town of that name, famous for its thermal springs and featured in Agatha Christie novels as the birthplace of the detective Hercule Poirot. Spa was and is still a favorite destination for "wellness"-seeking Europeans. The French Riviera (Cote d'Azur) has also a history as a wellness getaway for English and Russian nobilities who wanted to escape the cold winters of northern Europe,
In more recent history, medical tourism followed advances in medicine as rich people from developing countries travelled to more developed countries such as the US and the UK for medical treatment that they could not obtain in their home country. One of the most well-published cases is that of Chilean president Alberto Pinochet who went to England for medical treatment but was arrested by Spanish authorities for human rights violations. Other countries (e.g. Switzerland) specialized in boutique health services, such as cosmetic surgery and rehabilitation clinics, have also their own niche for the rich and famous who appreciate the comfort and discretion offered.
Globalization and widespread air travel have triggered the rise in medical tourism, bringing about two major trends in health tourism.
(1) Medical tourism has gone mainstream.
Whereas before, only the rich and the famous could afford to be medical tourists, medical tourism is now accessible to everybody. Hundreds of travel agencies have specialized in this rather lucrative niche. In Europe, where crossing national borders now have fewer restrictions with the inclusion of eastern European countries to the European Union, medical tourism has become widespread. This is aided by the short distances and the fact that the health care destinations are reachable by car, by train or a short flight. For Americans, medical tourism may entail travelling long distances but with cheaper flights, Central American countries have become favorite destinations. Citizens of states bordering Mexico and Canada, have of course, better access to their neighbors' health care offerings.
(2) Medical tourism has changed directions.
Medical tourism of 50 years ago mainly consisted of trips from a less developed country to a more developed and medically advanced country. Nowadays medical tourism goes in both directions, but mainly in the direction of developing countries where good quality but affordable healthcare can be found.
The current trends in medical tourism may be due to the following factors:
(1) Rising health care costs.
The rising health care costs in developed countries especially the US are forcing their citizens to seek affordable health care elsewhere. Here's an example of how much cheaper medical tourism can be: Charges for common procedures such as heart bypass can be $11,000 in Thailand compared to $130,000 in the United States. Knee replacement in the United States can cost $40,000 compared to $13,000 in Singapore.
This is even encouraged by health insurance companies and employers offering coverage of medical tourism expenses. One case is that of the insurer WellPoint Inc. and a self-funded, Wisconsin-based specialty graphics business called Serigraph. According to reports, "Serigraph will waive co-pays and coinsurance for any of their 650 employees to fly to India for certain non-emergency medical procedures such as major joint replacement and upper and lower back fusion. In addition, Serigraph will pay for all travel expenses for the employee as well as a companion." The message is clear: medical tourism is more cost-effective than getting treatment locally.
(2) Cross-border medical training.
More and more doctors from developing countries have studied and specialized abroad, thus bring home advanced medical technology and practices. India, for example, has many doctors trained in the US and the UK who speak excellent English and fully understand the medical needs of medical tourists from Western countries. The same is true for Mexico in relation to the US and Australia in relation to Thailand.
(3)Holistic approach to medicine.
The last decade also witnessed the popularity of alternative and complementary medicine. More and more people opt for a holistic approach to medical treatment and seek out alternative health care such as traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurveda (India), Unani (Arabic), homeopathy, and herbal medicine, among others. Many countries in Asia offer these types of medicine for Western tourists.
(4)Accreditation.
To overcome the scepticism of patients, many medical tourism facilities apply for accreditation. Several American organizations conduct inspections, evaluations of and grant accreditation to medical facilities outside the US. One of these is the Joint Commission International (JCI), which is the international subsidiary of JACHO, the USA focused Joint Accreditation Commission for HealthCare Organisations. More encompassing is accreditation by the International Society for Quality in Healthcare which is the umbrella organization for accreditation agencies in many countries including Australia, New Zealand, Japan, Canada and Ireland.
The most popular destinations are in Asia and Latin America. However, it is estimated that about 50 countries in all continents engage in the industry.
India is on top of the list of favorite medical tourism destinations. As previously mentioned, India has the advantage of having capable doctors, some of them trained in the West. An additional advantage is the lack of language barrier that many other countries are facing because almost everybody in India speaks English. Finally, India is the understandably the preferred choice of millions of Indians living and working abroad.
According a University of Delaware article "India has top-notch centers for open-heart surgery, pediatric heart surgery, hip and knee replacement, cosmetic surgery, dentistry, bone marrow transplants and cancer therapy, and virtually all of India’s clinics are equipped with the latest electronic and medical diagnostic equipment." It seems that Indian doctors as also open to innovation and offer uncommon but effective interventions. "For example, hip surgery patients in India can opt for a hip-resurfacing procedure, in which damaged bone is scraped away and replaced with chrome alloy--an operation that costs less and causes less post-operative trauma than the traditional replacement procedure performed in the U.S". In addition, assisted reproduction has become a big hit in India where there is less regulation (see below). In 2007, an estimated 150,000 medical tourists from the US, UK and other countries visited India. The popularity of India is due to three major attractions:highly trained English-speaking doctors, quick appointments and bargain-basement prices. In India, a heart bypass goes for $10,000 and a hip replacement for $9,000, compared with $130,000 and $43,000 respectively in the United States".
Thailand has several medical facilities with accreditations from the US. Aside from the additional attraction of its holiday destination facilities the beaches of Phuket, Thailand is actually well-known for sex-change surgery, which "is one of the top 10 procedures for which patients visit Thailand." Thailand is also a popular destination for assisted reproduction.
For Americans, Mexico and Costa Rica are appealing because of their proximity. According to the Washington Post, Mexico is "quickly transforming its border cities into catch basins for millions of bargain-hunting and uninsured Americans. Arizona retirement communities now organize regular bus tours for Mexican dental work and inexpensive drugs. New hospitals have opened in Tijuana, because some U.S. health plans have begun covering services in Mexico. And tiny border communities, some about an hour from Ciudad Juarez, are becoming dentistry boomtowns to handle an ever-growing flow of American patients flying in from as far away as Alaska."
Despite the boom in medical tourism and global healthcare the industry remains controversial in several respects.
(1) Health care disparities.
A main objection by those who are opposed to medical tourism is the disparities of care delivered by private facilities catering to medical tourists and public health care for local residents. Again, taking India as example, according to the World Health Organization (WHO), private expenditure on health as a percentage of total expenditure on health in 2003 was 75%. That contrasted starkly with government expenditure of 25% in the same year, a portion which finances public health facilities that cater to most of India’s population. It is estimated more than half of India's primary health care facilities are not equipped with a labor room, laboratory, or a telephone or stocked with essential medications.
(2) Circumventing the law: IVF
In January 2009, a Canadian woman made headlines when she delivered twins at the age of 60. Under Canadian law, the age limit for a woman to have in vitro fertilization (IVF) is 45 to years old. To circumvent this, the Indian-born woman had the IVF procedure performed in India. India is the home of the world's oldest first-time mother who delivered a baby girl last November at the age of 70. Laws governing fertility treatments are almost nonexistent in India, and unlike in many countries, there are no regulations limiting the age of the mother or the number of embryos implanted. The country's "medical culture emphasises the mother's right to create life rather than the rights of a child".
(3) Wombs for hire
Another form of assisted reproduction connected with medical tourism is commercial surrogacy or reproductive outsourcing and again India is in the front line. Women whose uteri are not capable of carrying a baby resort to paying other women to be surrogate mothers. In India, women consider this as a respectable way of making money and at the same time help childless women. "Commercial surrogacy has been legal in India since 2002, as it is in many other countries, including the United States. But India is the leader in making it a viable industry rather than a rare fertility treatment. Experts say it could take off for the same reasons outsourcing in other industries has been successful: a wide labor pool working for relatively low rates."
(4) Organ transplant
One of the shady dealings of medical tourism is organ transplantation. In Europe and North America, people have to be on a waiting list for organ transplants. Eligibility for organ transplants depends on blood match and how sick a patient is. People who are not willing to wait and can afford to pay a lot of money may find other means of getting an organ in developing countries. "Transplant tourism" as it is sometimes called, is thriving in developing countries. A recent report in FoxNews featured young Egyptian adults who sell their kidneys in underground organ trafficking in Cairo. In 2006, The Guardian reported that British patients travelled to China to have transplants with organs taken from executed prisoners, "without the prior consent of either the prisoner or their family," a practice strongly condemned by the British Transplantation Society.
Medical tourism is on the rise and is expected to become more popular and acceptable in the future. According to the American Medical Association, "the global economy and changing rules of trade provide opportunities and challenges for the medical profession and public health". Like in any industry, medical tourism is ruled by supply and demand. There is definitely a lot of demand in developed countries that developing countries willingly supply. However, the limits and regulations need to be set in place in order to protect the patients as well as the labor force of the service providers. Only then can the industry be worthy of the term "global healthcare".
References:
60-year-old Calgary mother welcomes twins. CBCnews Canada. February 5, 2009.
American Medical Association. Globalization. AMA Health Care Trends 2008.
Chicago Tribune. For big surgery, Delhi is dealing. March 28, 2008.
Dyess D. Major Health Insurer to Cover Medical Procedures Abroad. HealthNews Nov 15 2008.
Egypt Pressured to Act on Underground Organ Trade. March 17, 2009. FoxNews.
Giving birth the latest job outsourced to India. Dec. 30, 2007 MSNBC.
Jones CA, Keith LG. Medical tourism and reproductive outsourcing: the dawning of a new paradigm for healthcare. Int J Fertil Womens Med. 2006 Nov-Dec;51(6):251-5.
Lagace M. The Rise of Medical Tourism. Harvard Business School Working Knowledge, Dec 17 2007.
Medical tourism growing worldwide. U Daily. University of Delaware. Jul 25, 2005.
Medical Toursim Magazine. Accreditation of Overseas Hospitals JCI or ISQua.
Roig-Franzia M. Discount Dentistry, South of the Border. Washington Post. June 18, 2007.
The world's oldest mother. March 6, 2009. The Guardian UK.
WHO. Medical visas mark growth of Indian medical tourism. Bulletin of the World Health Organization (BLT). Volume 85, Number 3, March 2007, 161-244.
York D.Medical tourism: the trend toward outsourcing medical procedures to foreign countries. J Contin Educ Health Prof. 2008 Spring;28(2):99-102.
Previous Articles from "Heads or Tails"
|
|
| 8/6/2010 | |
| Milk, Bread and... Medical Care? Healthcare goes Retail | |
| You know the routine – up early, make breakfast, packs kids’ lunches, telephone the carpool mom, dash to work, run out at lunch to pick up a few groceries, back for afternoon meetings, make a fast getaway to pick up the kids from soccer, arrive at home in time to make dinner while helping kids with homework. Your partner arrives at home then you’re out to the PTO meeting, choir rehearsal or library building committee. You finally get home, exchange a few words with your other half, check a few emails then off to bed. Tomorrow, the cycle starts again. | |
| Read the full article >> | |
| 5/28/2010 | |
| Adult Stem Cell Therapy - Ready for Prime Time? No moral issue here; it’s all about risk versus benefit. | |
| When you see the words 'stem cell,' you might reasonably expect to read some debate about the ethical appropriateness of using stem cells from discarded fetuses for research. This emotional issue has dominated the dialog regarding stem cell usage for the past decade. However, here’s a fascinating component that doesn’t receive much press. Stem cells don’t just exist in the embryo. There are stem cells in the adult body as well and these 'adult stem cells' are necessary for tissue regeneration throughout life. | |
| Read the full article >> | |
| 4/5/2010 | |
| Cancer Screening: Life-Savers or Expensive Luxury? | |
| Cancer is the second cause of mortality in the developed world. One of the most important developments in cancer research in recent years have been screening techniques that detect cancer in its early stages. The earlier the cancer is detected, the better are the chances of treatment and hopefully, the prognosis is better! | |
| Read the full article >> | |
| 1/11/2010 | |
| Soy: Friend or Foe? | |
| Remember when soy or soya was the wonder food of the 90s? In the form of tofu or bean curd, it was purported to be the perfect protein source without the bad health effects of meat, plus low in fat and calories. And for those who were lactose intolerant, especially little babies, soy milk was a god-sent milk substitute that was both protein-rich and healthy. For vegetarians, soy and soy products were the perfect substitute for meat and dairy products. In addition to its health benefits, soy and soy products were cheap and easily available. Even government health agencies such as the US FDA went so far as to allow soy food labeling with health claims on the association between soy protein and the reduced risk of coronary heart disease. | |
| Read the full article >> | |
| 9/30/2009 | |
| If You Think 'Organic' Food is 'Organic', Think Again | |
| The last decade has witnessed an increased interest in things 'organic' as more and more consumers seek out products that are healthy, ethical, and environmentally friendly. Nowhere is this more evident that in the food industry. In fact, the organic food industry has gone from a cottage industry start up to a multi-billion dollar business in less than a decade. This is especially true in developed countries of North America and Europe where consumers can afford to choose. | |
| Read the full article >> | |

