To boost or not to boost? That is the question facing countries fortunate enough to have vaccinated much of their adult population - Ewen Callaway


image by: WATE 6 On Your Side


While most countries are still cranking up their vaccination drives, some are already making plans to deliver millions of booster shots into arms later this year.

Concerns that Covid-19 may morph into a seasonal menace are driving preparations in the U.S., the European Union and the U.K. for a winter vaccine booster program. The plans are precautionary, according to public-health officials, and it isn’t yet certain they will be put into operation or at what scale.

Disease experts say the need for a winter vaccine drive will depend on whether vaccine-induced immunity fades over time and if the current crop of vaccines are effective against virus variants.

Scientists are still gathering data on both those issues, and the answers they find will shape the design of any booster program, including who would get one and which vaccine they might receive.

Some public-health experts say talk of booster programs is premature, given the gaps in our knowledge about the virus and the vaccines that combat it, as well as the urgent need for shots in countries such as India where the virus is spreading rapidly. “We need to have data’’ to determine if and when third doses are needed, the European Medicines Agency’s head of biological health threats and vaccines strategy, Marco Cavaleri, said this month.

But others say governments are right to move fast rather than wait for these questions to be settled.

“There is no point planning it if you have already got a resurgence,” said David Salisbury, a former director of immunization programs in the U.K. who is now an associate fellow in global health at the international affairs think tank Chatham House.

The EU said this month that it signed a contract with Pfizer Inc. and BioNTech SE of Germany for another 1.8 billion doses of their Covid-19 vaccine for delivery through 2023. The European Commission, the bloc’s executive arm, said the doses have been earmarked for booster shots and donations, or reselling if they aren’t needed. The population of the EU is almost 450 million, meaning that order alone would be enough to give everyone in the bloc two shots, in addition to the millions of shots already administered.

The U.K. said in April it ordered 60 million more doses of the Pfizer and BioNTech shot as part of its preparations for a fall and winter booster program. Health Secretary Matt Hancock said the plans are aimed at ensuring the elderly and vulnerable have the greatest possible protection against disease heading into the colder months, when increased indoor gathering gives the virus more chance to spread. Scientists in the U.K. on Wednesday began recruiting for a clinical trial to investigate the effects of a third dose of vaccine on volunteers’ immune responses.

In the U.S., David Kessler, chief science officer of the White House Covid-19 response team, told lawmakers in April that booster shots might be needed within a year, and if so they will be provided free of charge, with the elderly likely first in line. The U.S. is forecast to amass a surplus of 300 million doses of five vaccines by the end of 2021, even after assuming all adults and children over 5 years old are vaccinated, according to projections from health and science data company Airfinty Ltd.

Some vaccines, such as those given in childhood for measles, mumps and rubella, offer lifelong immunity against disease. For others, booster shots are recommended at periodic intervals or if the risk of exposure climbs. Adult booster shots for tetanus and meningitis are a common feature of national immunization schedules.

Influenza, by contrast, mutates quickly and shots are tailor-made each year to protect people against circulating strains.

Exactly where the vaccines developed against Covid-19 fit on this spectrum isn’t yet clear. Some scientists are optimistic the vaccines will confer long-lasting immunity, while others aren’t so sure. Another issue is whether existing vaccines provide sufficient protection against variants of concern, such as those first identified in South Africa and India, and if they will stand up to any new variants that may yet emerge.

“We don’t have a full picture of what the pathway is to protection,” said Gigi Gronvall, an immunologist and associate professor at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.

Complicating both questions are the different technologies being used in the world’s armory of vaccines. Shots that use an inactivated virus to stimulate the immune system might perform differently from others that use messenger RNA, a molecule that directs cells to make antibodies against the virus. Little is known about the risk of side effects from multiple doses.

Governments considering booster programs also face logistical hurdles, such as whether to vaccinate everyone or just the elderly and vulnerable.

Paul Hunter, professor of medicine at the University of East Anglia, said it wouldn’t be a surprise if vaccine-induced immunity diminished over time, as a similar phenomenon is seen in natural infection with other coronaviruses.

The evidence for Covid-19 vaccines so far is limited and inconclusive: Pfizer and BioNTech have said their vaccine is around 91% effective against Covid-19 six months after a second dose, down slightly from the 95% level observed in clinical trials.

Evidence of waning immunity would strengthen the case for a third dose to top up people’s protection as winter approaches, said Prof. Hunter. Existing vaccines would still have a role to play in booster programs if they bolster protection against widely circulating strains such as B.1.1.7, a variant first detected in England, while newer vaccines aimed more squarely at other variants move through clinical trials and regulatory scrutiny, said Prof. Salisbury.

Moderna Inc., for instance, is developing a vaccine tuned to fight the South Africa variant B.1.351. GlaxoSmithKline PLC is working with Germany’s CureVac NV on an early-stage vaccine designed to combat multiple variants, and with Sanofi SA on a more advanced candidate the companies say could be deployed as a booster shot, after trials pointed to a robust immune response in people already exposed to the virus.

For some scientists, the case for Western nations using up more shots while the pandemic rages elsewhere is weak. Peter English, a public-health physician who worked as a consultant in using vaccines to control infectious diseases, said he is skeptical that immunity will wane significantly anytime soon in those who have been fully vaccinated and doses of first-generation vaccines could be put to better use.

“If we’re not going to use a variant vaccine, we’d be better off shipping the vaccine to India or somewhere where they need it more than we do,” he said.

Source: Jason Douglas, Covid-19 Vaccine Booster Shots Raise Tough Issues for Health Authorities, The Wall Street Journal, May 20, 2021.

Related Articles

Stay Connected

©2017 | Health WorldNet, Inc.

Last Updated : Tuesday, August 24, 2021